Scheming Demon sounds like he's right on the money.
The pedal shouldn't be the issue, but I'll say this, when it came time for me to buy a pedal, I considered the pedal that you are using, but was unsatisfied with the adjustments that it has. I opted for the Tama Iron Cobra, it was more adjustable.
Definitely experiment with the throne adjustment though, it sure makes a difference.
Another thing (and partially why I passed by the pearl pedal) is the pedalboard angle. It should be set to the angle that your foot swings out to when you walk.
You might be interested in Joe Stronsick's Ballistic Drumming technique.
www.ballisticdrumming.comIt costs money, but he's also got a week of free email mini lessons that he'll do, so its worth looking into. He'll send you a fee CD for a little taste, too.