So yeah...thanks for all the suggestions guys. At least I know which heads to get. Wait, no I don't... 

Ok, considering the possibility that you really are confused on what to get I'll help you. It just depends on what kind of sound you want. I play a more Hard Rock/Progressive style of music and I feel that my Evans G2 coated heads are perfect for the sound I want. Pinstripes, however, give a completely different kind of sound. More "Poppy" or "Main Stream Rockish". I apologize that I started this whole debate but thats my whole take on the drum head situation. It really depends on what you want sound-wise. I hope this helps. 

This isn't too surprising.  Most guys replace the stock heads with better quality heads.  This almost always results in a better sound - assuming the guy knows how to tune.